Jusletter

Dispute Resolution at the America’s Cup

  • Auteur-e: Thomas Schultz
  • Domaines juridiques: Sport
  • Proposition de citation: Thomas Schultz, Dispute Resolution at the America’s Cup, in : Jusletter 5. September 2005
The America´s Cup is one of the most prestigious and oldest sports events in the world. The stakes involved are huge, be it only in financial terms. Moreover, it is organized in an almost entirely autonomous fashion, in the sense that the respective defender of the Cup (the sailing club that last won the Cup), along with its first challenger are almost completely free to organize the competition as they see fit, the only real constraint being a 150-years old two-pages document. The combination of this liberty and the stakes just mentioned lead, over the years, to a series of interesting adjustment as regards the way dispute arising in the context of the Cup are resolved. From long and bitter litigation in connection with Dennis Conner´s famous catamaran, the sailing community has learned the importance of providing for extra-judicial methods and bodies. These methods and bodies have, over the last editions of the America´s Cup, gradually evolved, thereby revealing likely strong points and pitfalls in the setting up of ad hoc dispute resolution. This article first introduces the various documents and rules that govern the Cup. It then goes back over the court proceedings that sparked the intention to equip this sporting event with private dispute resolution mechanisms. Thereafter, it presents the three different dispute resolution bodies that accompanied the five last editions of the Cup. Finally, this article reviews the jurisprudence (11 arbitral awards so far) of the current edition of the Cup.

Table of contents

  • I. Introduction
  • II. Historical and legal background
  • 1. The Deed of Gift and its sources of interpretation
  • 2. Protocol
  • 3. The Mercury Bay Saga and the Need to Avoid Court Litigation
  • III. Dispute resolution bodies
  • 1. The 28th and 29th editions´ Trustees Committee
  • 2. The 30th and 31st editions´ America´s Cup Arbitration Panel
  • 3. The 32nd edition´ America´s Cup Jury
  • a. Jurisdiction
  • b. Composition
  • c. Procedural aspects
  • IV. The Jury jurisprudence related to the 32nd America´s Cup
  • 1. Designers and other team members
  • 2. Sailing rules and situations
  • 3. Yachts
  • 4. Management aspects of the event
  • V. Conclusion

Aucun commentaire

Es gibt noch keine Kommentare

Votre commentaire sur cet article

Les abonné-e-s à cette revue peuvent prendre part à la discussion. Veuillez vous connecter pour poster des commentaires.